From a major waterfront celebration to Broadway performers, autumn festivals and a few unexpected outings,… Read More →
From big-name performers to local celebrations and a few unexpected outings, here’s where to go… Read More →
With deer mating season underway, AAA warns Hamptons and North Fork drivers to stay alert… Read More →
Union finds a new Southampton home, CVS Pharmacy prepares to open at Bridgehampton’s new Target,… Read More →
The Ronkonkoma airport, owned and operated by the Town of Islip, takes the No. 1… Read More →
The bestselling author and clinical psychologist brings her approach to conscious parenting to Ross School… Read More →
The brothers, whose crimes extended to the Hamptons, face sentencing Oct. 27. Prosecutors cite at… Read More →
From ‘The Studio’ co-creator Alex Gregory, the new series explores wealth, ambition and the relationships… Read More →
The East Hampton reception brought together art, wine and philanthropy, with wines from Ridley Scott’s… Read More →
Hundreds of people and their canine companions made their way from Mulford Farm to the… Read More →
Alexander Brothers: Prosecutors Seek Life Sentences for Former Luxury Real Estate Brokers
The brothers, whose crimes extended to the Hamptons, face sentencing Oct. 27. Prosecutors cite at least 70 victims, while federal probation officials recommend prison terms of up to 195 years.
Federal prosecutors are seeking life sentences for Tal, Oren and Alon Alexander, the three brothers convicted in a sweeping sex trafficking case involving allegations of drugging and raping women over two decades, including at luxury properties and exclusive gatherings in the Hamptons.
In a sentencing memorandum filed Wednesday, Oct. 14, prosecutors in Manhattan described the brothers’ offenses as “sex crimes of extraordinary magnitude,” arguing that their years-long pattern of sexual abuse warrants life imprisonment.
“They spent years designing, executing, and perfecting their playbook of luring victims with promises of luxury, drugging victims so they could not resist, and then forcibly raping them,” prosecutors wrote.
The brothers are scheduled to be sentenced Oct. 27 in federal court in Manhattan. Their attorneys are seeking 15-year prison terms, while the federal Probation Office has recommended sentences of 180 years each for Tal and Alon Alexander and 195 years for Oren Alexander.
Prosecutors said they identified at least 70 women who were raped or sexually assaulted by one or more of the brothers. Eleven women testified during their federal trial earlier this year.
The sentencing request marks another chapter in the downfall of Tal and Oren Alexander, once among the country’s most prominent luxury real estate brokers. Known as real estate’s “A Team,” they built their reputations handling multimillion-dollar properties for wealthy and celebrity clients in New York, Miami and the Hamptons.
A Pattern of Abuse Spanning Two Decades
Tal, 40, and twins Oren and Alon, 39, were convicted on all 10 counts in March following a five-week federal trial, including charges involving sex trafficking and the sexual exploitation of minors.
Prosecutors said the brothers began sexually assaulting women as early as 2001 or 2002, when they were still in high school. Over time, they allegedly developed a pattern of enticing women to exclusive parties, luxury vacations and private residences, where they drugged and sexually assaulted them.
“The defendants felt empowered to take whatever they wanted from any woman or girl who agreed to get on a plane, go to a party, or sit at their table at a nightclub,” prosecutors wrote.
The evidence presented at trial described incidents involving Manhattan apartments, Hamptons mansions, Aspen, Colorado, and a Caribbean cruise.
Jurors heard testimony from 11 accusers, many of whom described becoming disoriented or losing control of their bodies after accepting drinks from one of the brothers. The prosecution also presented video evidence, photographs and electronic communications.
Tal and Oren worked as high-profile luxury real estate brokers, while Alon ran the family’s private security company.
Spark Hamptons previously covered the convictions in The Fall of Real Estate’s A-Team: Alexander Brothers Convicted of Sex Trafficking and the prosecution’s case in Inside the Alexander Brothers Sex Trafficking Trial: Prosecutor Rests Its Case.
Defense Seeks 15 Years and Plans to Appeal
Attorneys for the brothers filed their own sentencing memorandum Tuesday, requesting 15-year prison terms, the mandatory minimum applicable to certain charges.
Despite the jury’s verdict, the brothers continue to maintain their innocence.
“At no time did Alon, Oren or Tal rape or sexually assault another person,” their attorneys wrote.
The defense acknowledged that the brothers had engaged in behavior that was “at times, insensitive toward the feelings of certain women,” and apologized to women they had insulted or offended, but rejected the prosecution’s characterization of their conduct as criminal.
Their attorneys described the brothers as “dedicated husbands and fathers” and argued that life sentences would deprive their young children of their fathers throughout their childhoods.
The defense also signaled plans to challenge the convictions on appeal, calling the evidence “remarkably weak” on critical points and arguing that rulings by U.S. District Judge Valerie Caproni had unfairly prejudiced the jury.
The brothers have remained jailed since their arrests in December 2024.
Sentencing Set for Oct. 27
Caproni will determine the sentences for all three brothers Oct. 27.
The judge has also scheduled a hearing to consider whether the brothers should be housed together or separately in federal prison. Their attorneys have argued that keeping them together would help protect their safety and mental health while incarcerated.
The sentencing decision will determine whether the three brothers, whose former lives revolved around luxury real estate and exclusive social circles, spend the remainder of their lives in prison.
