A Broadway Holiday: Betsy Wolfe Brings “The Most Wonderful Time” to Guild Hall

Tony Award-nominated Broadway star Betsy Wolfe brings her powerhouse voice, quick wit and unmistakable stage presence to East Hampton for an evening of holiday favorites, musical surprises and a little Broadway magic.

This holiday season, Broadway is coming to East Hampton in a big way. On Saturday, November 28, Tony nominee Betsy Wolfe brings her festive musical show, The Most Wonderful Time, to Guild Hall. If you love powerhouse vocals, comedy, and those warm moments that make live shows special, you’ll want to mark your calendar.

Betsy Wolfe. Photo: www.guildhall.org

Betsy Wolfe has become one of Broadway’s go-to stars, not just for her vocal chops, but for her ability to connect and make any crowd feel right at home. She’s got the kind of stage presence that pulls you in, whether she’s belting out a showstopper or slowing things down for something heartfelt.

For this holiday performance, Wolfe is leaving her usual Broadway roles behind. She’s mixing up the classics with new favorites and even tossing in a few musical surprises. Of course, true to form, you can expect her signature humor and storytelling woven throughout the night.

A Versatile, Broadway Powerhouse

It’s the perfect setup for someone as versatile as Wolfe. She’s done everything from musical theater productions to intimate cabaret and concert gigs. Broadway first took notice when she snagged roles in shows like 110 in the Shade, The Mystery of Edwin Drood, and Bullets Over Broadway. She wowed audiences as Cordelia in Falsettos and became a familiar name thanks to Waitress, a Tony-nominated musical by Sara Bareilles.

Her recent turn as Anne Hathaway in & Juliet scored her a 2023 Tony nomination and showed off her knack for combining vocal power with comedy and real emotional depth. Wolfe also starred in Death Becomes Her, taking on the stage version of the cult movie, and created the title role in Joy, inspired by the inventor Joy Mangano. Off Broadway, she’s delivered acclaimed performances in The Last Five Years and Merrily We Roll Along.

www.guildhall.org

Wolfe isn’t just a theater star. She debuted at the Metropolitan Opera in Die Fledermaus and has sung with more than 60 orchestras around the world. She co-founded BroadwayEvolved, a training program for young performers, pushing the next generation toward their dreams.

But for this show at Guild Hall, the vibe is more relaxed. It’s about sharing the joy of the holidays, connecting with the community, and celebrating the season together.

Showstoppers, Classic Holiday Tunes and Lots of Favorites & Surprises

The Most Wonderful Time will bounce from big, show-stopping musical numbers to tender moments — expect classic holiday tunes, fresh twists on old favorites, and some theatrical surprises. Plus, you’ll get plenty of Wolfe’s off-the-cuff humor.

You don’t have to be a Broadway fanatic to enjoy this one. It’s a holiday concert for the whole family, a chance to kick off the season and see a top performer in the cozy atmosphere that makes Guild Hall such a staple in East Hampton.

If you’re a Guild Hall member, you get discounted tickets, so it’s a great excuse to check out their membership perks.

A little Broadway shine, loads of holiday joy, and Betsy Wolfe leading the charge. This is how you start the season right.

IF YOU GO

WHAT: Betsy Wolfe: The Most Wonderful Time
WHEN: Saturday, November 28, 2026
TIME: 7–8:30 p.m.
WHERE: Guild Hall, 158 Main Street, East Hampton, NY 11937
FEATURING: Betsy Wolfe, Tony Award-nominated Broadway star
TICKETS: Reservations are recommended; members enjoy discounted pricing.

For tickets and more info, head to Guild Hall.