East Hampton Fires Building Chief Hired to Fix Troubled Department

Richard Normoyle Jr. is out after 14 months, leaving questions about the town’s efforts to tackle years of permit delays and a bribery scandal involving two former employees.

The man hired to fix East Hampton Town’s troubled Building Department has been fired just 14 months into the job, leaving the town’s efforts to tackle years of permit delays and mounting backlogs facing another leadership change.

Richard Normoyle Jr., brought in to overhaul the department in September 2025, was dismissed by a unanimous Town Board vote Thursday, Nov. 19, as questions persist over the agency’s ability to deliver timely building approvals.

The board voted 5-0 to terminate Normoyle’s employment, effective immediately. The resolution offered no explanation beyond citing applicable civil service laws and rules.

The dismissal comes as the department continues to face complaints from homeowners, contractors, architects and real estate professionals over the time it takes to secure building permits, inspections and certificates of occupancy.

The agency has also been rocked by a bribery scandal involving two former employees who admitted accepting payments from contractors to expedite building approvals. The misconduct occurred before Normoyle joined the town, and he has not been implicated in the case.

His departure raises a larger question: What happens now to East Hampton’s efforts to fix a department whose problems have frustrated residents and building professionals for years?\

Richard Normoyle Jr.. East Hampton Town Building Department

Hired to Fix a Troubled Department

Normoyle joined East Hampton Town in September 2025 as principal building inspector, earning $135,000 annually. He was promoted to chief building inspector in June 2026, with a salary of $140,000.

His assignment was to improve operations, reduce the backlog of applications and restore confidence in a department facing mounting criticism over lengthy processing times.

The town expanded the department’s staffing from approximately 10 to 19 positions, brought in outside firms to assist with plan reviews and introduced a new online application system in March.

The department’s goals included reducing permit processing times and clearing its backlog by the end of 2026.

Despite the town’s efforts to improve processing times, lengthy delays have continued to frustrate homeowners and building professionals. The problems have also led to legal action against the town.

Permit Delays Lead to Lawsuit Against Town

For some East Hampton property owners, the wait for building approvals has gone beyond frustration and into the courtroom.

In 2026, Amagansett property owners Joseph Macari and Kim Staller brought an Article 78 proceeding against the East Hampton Town Building Department after their application to construct a home at 20 Bendigo Road remained unresolved for months.

The couple submitted their application Dec. 24, 2025. By June, the department had neither approved nor denied it.

On June 10, Suffolk County Supreme Court Justice Alison J. Napolitano ordered the department to act on the application within 15 days, citing the town code’s requirement that permit applications receive a decision within that period.

The judge did not order the town to approve the permit, but required it to issue either an approval or denial.

The town appealed the ruling.

The lawsuit underscored the conflict between the town’s written requirements and the much longer processing times experienced by applicants.

A Freedom of Information Law request fulfilled in June showed more than 700 building permit applications pending in East Hampton Town.

Two Former Building Department Employees Plead Guilty to Bribery

The department’s longstanding difficulties have been compounded by a criminal investigation involving two former employees.

Evelyn Calderon, 47, of Mastic, a former senior office assistant, and Ryan Benitez, 38, of East Hampton, a former building inspector, pleaded guilty Sept. 30 and Oct. 1, respectively, to five felony counts of third-degree bribe receiving and five misdemeanor counts of official misconduct each.

According to the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office, the two accepted cash payments from contractors in 2024 to move building permits and certificates of occupancy ahead of other applications.

Prosecutors said Calderon advanced applications submitted by paying contractors and shared the money with Benitez, who expedited inspections.

In some cases, permits that ordinarily took months were issued within days after payments were made.

Both former employees are scheduled to be sentenced Dec. 2. Their anticipated sentences include five years of probation and 840 hours of community service.

The conduct at the center of the case occurred before Normoyle was hired in September 2025.

Questions Over Normoyle’s Departure

The circumstances surrounding Normoyle’s dismissal remain unclear.

Speculation had circulated that he might leave East Hampton for a position with Southampton Village. Meanwhile, the town’s proposed 2027 budget included an increase in compensation for the chief building inspector position.

But on Wednesday, Nov. 18, Normoyle denied that he had resigned.

The following day, the Town Board voted to terminate his employment.

Supervisor Kathee Burke-Gonzalez moved the resolution, which Councilwoman Cate Rogers seconded. All five board members voted in favor.

Normoyle was still serving a probationary period associated with his June promotion.

The town has not publicly disclosed a specific reason for the dismissal.

The department had also faced questions earlier this year about Normoyle’s New York State code enforcement certification.

In September, the town acknowledged that his previous certification had become inactive during his years outside municipal government and that additional requirements had not been completed when he returned to code enforcement work.

According to the town, Normoyle completed the necessary examinations and was recertified Aug. 25.

There has been no public indication that the certification issue was connected to his dismissal.

During the Nov. 19 Town Board meeting, resident David Buda expressed surprise at the termination and called for an explanation. Board members did not publicly respond.

Associate Administrator Allison McDougall will assume certain departmental responsibilities while the town begins the civil service process of selecting a new department head.

East Hampton Town Hall. Photo: Wikipedia

What’s Next for East Hampton’s Building Department?

The department issued 1,342 building permits, conducted 3,257 inspections and issued 722 certificates of occupancy in 2025, according to town figures.

The town has invested in additional staffing, outside consultants and technology intended to improve operations.

It also temporarily suspended enforcement of a requirement for updated certificates of occupancy when properties change hands, allowing the department additional time to process outstanding applications. That suspension is scheduled to run through Dec. 31, 2026.

Yet the central issue remains unresolved for many property owners and building professionals: how long it takes to obtain the approvals necessary to begin construction, complete renovations or close real estate transactions.

With Normoyle’s departure, East Hampton must once again find a leader to continue the department’s overhaul.

For residents and businesses waiting on permits, the question is less about who occupies the chief inspector’s office than whether the town can finally deliver a building approval process that is timely, transparent and consistent.

After years of delays, a criminal investigation, legal challenges and another change in leadership, that question remains unanswered.

Angela LaGreca

Editor, Co-Founder/Publisher

Angela LaGreca, Editor-in-chief and co-Founder/Publisher of Spark Hamptons, is a four-time Emmy Award-winning journalist, producer, writer and comedian/host. Her TV credits include NBC’s “Today,” ABC’s “The View,” and, most recently, the primetime cable news program “Cuomo” on NewsNation. On the East End, she was the Creative Director at LTV, VP Features/Events/Photo Editor at Dan’s Papers, and has performed at Guild Hall, Bay Street Theater and the WHBPAC. Her publishing career began at Modern Photography, where she was managing editor. LaGreca lives in Manhattan and East Hampton and can be reached at angelatvmedia@gmail.com and angela@sparkhamptons.com .