The best fall festivals, fairs, film, food, music and harvest events across the Hamptons and… Read More →
Feline panleukopenia can be fatal, particularly for kittens and unvaccinated cats, and even indoor cats… Read More →
Olivia Colman, Alexander Skarsgård, Amanda Seyfried, John Turturro, Jesse Eisenberg and Ron Howard are among… Read More →
The annual waterfront festival returns Sept. 19-20 with whaleboat races, the fall arts and crafts… Read More →
Bonnie Kay Haydon, mother ofuth Vanessa Trump, is asking $3.75 million for the renovated three-bedroom… Read More →
From New York Fashion Week and the U.S. Open finals to the 100th Feast of… Read More →
The Southampton screening of LILLY featured a panel with Academy Award nominee Patricia Clarkson, executive… Read More →
Montauk seafood, dance at LongHouse, comedy, art and a Southampton house tour lead Spark Hamptons’… Read More →
New York Theatre Ballet Brings Krasner & Pollock / Uncaged to East Hampton New York… Read More →
Bonita DeWolf and Janifer Jaeger join the 150-year-old firm’s Sag Harbor office, bringing more than… Read More →
Shelter Island: Where the Hamptons Crowd Goes to Disappear
Tucked between the Hamptons and the North Fork, this ferry-only enclave is where the East End goes to actually relax
There’s a sliver of land floating between the increasingly un-chill Hamptons and the newer, scrappier North Fork — and that’s Shelter Island. Maybe it’s not as secret as it once was (thanks, Instagram), but it still reads Old Money in a linen shirt and loafers. The lack of a bridge helps — you’re hauling yourself and your beach bag onto a ferry and giving up cell service for the quiet cousin of Eastern Long Island. And yet, these last few years, the island’s gotten a genuine glow-up: restaurants you’ll daydream about next winter, design-forward hotels with actual personality, and, crucially, way fewer crowds than anywhere else out East.
Shelter Island’s tiny, but it packs in an abundance of beauty, things to do, and places to stay. In under half an hour, you can drive from ferry to ferry. Between the Americana-meets-Scandi hotels and B&Bs that feel straight out of social media, and new restaurants pulling people off the mainland just to snag a table, there’s a golden moment happening here — without losing its unbothered spirit. Take a walk in the Mashomack Preserve, get your feet dirty on a pebble beach, and you’ll remember why people called it off-the-map in the first place.
If you want a taste of Old East vibes but not the traffic, the lines, or the wallet bruising, Shelter Island’s your move. Here’s where to stay, eat, and shop, and what to do when the sun starts going golden à la the famous Hamptons light.
Where to Stay
The Boat House by DWR x Boutique
Skip the fantasy: you can actually pretend you own a waterfront Shelter Island house for the weekend at the Boathouse. Steps from the North Ferry, this new rental from Boutique Homes feels so grown-up with its three airy bedrooms and three and a half baths. Almost everything inside is shoppable, and “Design Within Reach” means exactly what it says — Scandi calm, Cali coastal sunshine, and a pinch of Long Island charm. The perks are serious: views of the harbor, a sprawling lawn, outdoor kitchen, hot tub, sauna, and more than enough room to convince your city friends you’re living the good life.
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin is Shelter’s grand old dame. Built in the ’20s, it’s all white clapboard, wide porches, and a sly whiff of summer camp nostalgia. After a recent renovation, the rooms are crisp and fresh but still have that Norman Rockwell vibe and genuine character. Pool, tennis, cruiser bikes, and sandy Crescent Beach outside your door. The real party’s out front — cocktails on the porch, perfected by the Dante team from NYC. It’s prime territory for people-watching as the sun goes down.
The Chequit Hotel
Perched in Shelter Heights, the Chequit pulls off that light-laced, salty-aired boutique vibe on its own terms. Rooms are all breezy blues and whites with water views, and you’re a flip-flop walk from indie coffee shops and little boutiques. The new restaurant’s all about coastal Italian twists, and the wraparound porch is perfect for your morning pastry and iced latte. For extra flex, the owners have a 1926 sailboat for private charters.
Sevens Shelter Island
It’s technically a B&B, but Sevens Shelter Island feels more like the house of your stylish, perpetually relaxed friend. Seven streamlined, modern king rooms flank the heated pool—pick your favorite towel, dig into the Euro-style breakfast, and hope someone remembered the prosecco. Easy win for a group takeover with actual privacy.
Where to Eat
Léon 1909
If you’re lucky enough to land a reservation, count your blessings — Léon’s wood-fired menu and coastal French-Italian flavors are worth any ferry wait. Montauk shrimp crudo, locally milled sourdough, the kind of burger people drive two hours for. Save room for dessert, or just do what everyone else does and sneak across to the Tuck Shop for something sweet.
Sunset Beach
André Balazs’s Sunset Beach is what you imagine people mean when they say “Riviera vibes,” imported straight into Shelter. Boats pull up, rosé flows, and the DJ starts spinning as the sun drops. Tuna tartare, figs and burrata, artichokes so perfect they barely need dressing—the crowd’s there for the scene, but the food’s not afterthought-level. It’s the one place where someone might clock your outfit.
Vine Street Café and Market
This is Shelter’s anchor: a bistro pulling from the farms and fishing docks nearby and turning out savory stuff even in the dead of winter. Start with the housemade pasta, don’t miss the Monday night bouillabaisse, and raid the adjacent market for addictive sauces, cheese, and snacks to take back to your rental.
Opties and Dinghies
A handwritten chalkboard menu. Dumplings next to giant scallion pancakes next to crêpes. This spot is a happy accident in the middle of the island — a labor of love from a husband-and-wife duo who scoop Il Laboratorio gelato and stash frozen treats to-go for next-day cravings.
Blue Han
Finally, a break from lobster rolls and clam pasta—Blue Han brings Korean comfort food, from bibimbap and seafood pancakes to spicy tteokbokki and banchan sets. The island’s leaning Euro, but Blue Han holds it down for anyone seeking a different kind of salt and spice.
You’ll want to know where to grab-and-go: Marie Eiffel Market for classic breakfast sandwiches and pastries, plus a trustworthy lobster roll. Peeko Oysters up the ante with bags of East End oysters, primed for your sunset shuck-and-slurp session.
What to Do
King Andrew Cheese
The cult-favorite cheese wagon is part roving delicatessen, part social club. Find it, eat every sample, and leave with a box of something you don’t know how to pronounce. If you miss the wagon, a self-serve fridge is usually stocked with plenty of wedges so you won’t go home empty-handed.
Mashomack Preserve
Shelter would be lost without Mashomack — 2,000 acres of woodsy trails, open fields, salt marshes, and wildlife that seem completely indifferent to your presence. Even on busy weekends, you’ll find entire stretches of path to yourself. Keep an eye out for foxes, ospreys, occasional celebrity walkers, and a picnic bench with your name on it.
Sylvester Manor
A historic estate that’s as earnest as a farmstand gets — Sylvester Manor covers 200 acres, mixes veggies and flowers with winding walking paths, and hosts good-natured outdoor art installations in season. The farmstand stocks produce, baked goods, and odds-and-ends charmed in from the North Fork.
SPRMRKT
Way in the back of the Shelter Island IGA — yes, the actual supermarket — SPRMRKT peddles some of the best, weirdest, and only slightly ironic Shelter-themed streetwear you’ll find. Think T-shirts and hoodies dressed up in butcher-counter-chic, courtesy of Anthony Peronace, local kid turned tastemaker. It’s a souvenir, but you’ll wear it back in the city, too.
Shelter Island Heights
Call it a downtown if you have to. This walkable few blocks are packed with boutiques stocking ceramics, striped towels, breezy caftans, and high-thread-count sheets. Stop at Purethread or Pure Soul Boutique for editors’ picks, then hit Finley’s Fiction bookshop for last-minute beach reading or a solid new release.
Black Cat Books
You need time — and a sense of humor — to love Black Cat. It’s crammed with collectible finds, oddities, and the kind of used books that outlasted four owners and a hurricane. Search long enough and you’ll come away with something unforgettable. Or at least a first edition Cat Who mystery.
IF YOU GO
STAY
The Boat House by DWR x Boutique
The Chequit Hotel — Shelter Island Heights
EAT
SEE, SHOP, DO
